• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

The Pizza Mafia Grill - Authentic Fairport NY Pizza & Specialty Subs

The Pizza Mafia Grill, located in Fairport, NY, stands out for its exceptional pizzas and hearty specialty sandwiches. Known for its flavorful crusts—crispy yet tender—and rich, savory sauces, this spot delivers consistently delicious meals that keep customers coming back. Highlights include the “Big Chooch” meatball sub, praised for its generous, succulent meatballs and fresh bread, and the “Goodfellas” specialty pizza, a fan favorite for its balanced toppings and satisfying taste. Friendly service and attention to quality, including fresh-cut veggies with wings, create an inviting experience. Ideal for takeout, The Pizza Mafia Grill offers authentic Italian-inspired comfort food that truly impresses.

The Pizza Mafia Grill at a glance

  • Address 1276 Fairport Rd Suite 4, Fairport, NY 14450, United States
  • Phone +1 585-673-2020
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .

Photos & Gallery

The Pizza Mafia Grill: Reviews & Ratings

Jason Rex
5

Best meatball sub of my life! Good bread, huge delicious meatballs, along with other meats as well. On the menu, Specialty Sandwiches - The Big Chooch. Sooo Good! (Sharpie marker in pic for scale) Edit: I've ordered this sub 4 times since my original review and it's great every time.

Brian Coe
5

My neighbors told us to try the pizza from Pizza Mafia and they raved about it. I had not eaten here since they took over from the previous pizza shop that was here. We ordered a sheet pizza and it was delivered quickly and piping hot. The sauce and ingredients were delicious but the crust was the real stand out. Fantastic pizza and best of all, the kids loved it better than any they had before. We will definitely order from here again.

Rosita Gilbert
5

This is the first time we have tried Pizza Mafia and let me tell you it is the best pizza we had in a long time! The crust consistency and sauce flavor were both amazing. The girl at the counter was super friendly and very engaging. We will definitely be returning! Keep up the good work!

Carl
5

We ate all the pizza and forgot to take photos. This pizza is really good. Even when you order it normal and not well done the crust is good and crunch and lasts past when it cools down which is hard to find. The guy who was working today was awesome. I’d return for sure. It’s a small place with only two seat tables and not many of them just due to the size of the shop. It may not the best place to bring the family to eat in but it would be worth ordering and bringing home!

Kassandra Degus
5

This pizza is amazing! The Goodfellas specialty pizza is our favorite. My husband says they have the best wings he's had in a long time AND they give you cut veggies on the side - something most area places have stopped doing. They're also open on Mondays, so if you're struggling to find a place for dinner that's actually open, here it is!

Ben Beavers
5

Friendly staff great food best cannoli any where! And try the "goodfellows pizza" it's exceptional. Been back several times always a delight. This small pizza place rank at the top of my list for all-time best pizza and it is the top of the list for best cannoli. We drive 35+ miles to eat here. It's worth the drive.

Location

  • The Pizza Mafia Grill
    The Pizza Mafia Grill
    1276 Fairport Rd Suite 4, Fairport, NY 14450, United States Hotline: +1 585-673-2020

Located in the heart of Fairport, NY, The Pizza Mafia Grill delivers an authentic and memorable pizza experience that stands out in a sea of ordinary eateries. From the moment you step in—or place a takeout order—you’re greeted with a warm atmosphere and a menu that promises more than just typical pie. What truly sets this spot apart is the perfect harmony between their crust, sauce, and toppings, creating a pizza that’s both crunchy and flavorful, even when cooled.

One can’t mention The Pizza Mafia Grill without highlighting the rave-worthy Specialty Sandwiches, especially the Big Chooch meatball sub. With its generous, juicy meatballs nestled between quality bread, it’s clear that the kitchen respects the craft of hearty, satisfying sandwiches. Jason Rex’s repeated orders underscore the consistent quality and crave-worthy nature of this sub.

The pizza itself shines in every review. Whether it’s the Goodfellas specialty pizza crowned a favorite by many or the classic pies delivered steaming hot and fresh, each bite reveals a careful layering of savory sauce, fresh ingredients, and that signature crust—crisp, yet resilient, holding its texture well after cooling. This balance speaks volumes about the attention given to every detail, from dough preparation to ingredient sourcing.

Beyond the food, the friendly and engaging staff add to the overall charm, making each visit or order feel personalized. Though the dine-in space is modest, intended more for quick bites than large family gatherings, the fast delivery and takeout options make it a reliable choice for any occasion, even on Mondays when many other places close.

In a town bustling with pizza places, The Pizza Mafia Grill quietly earns its spot as a standout. Whether you’re a fan of expertly crafted subs, crave a well-made pizza with a memorable crust, or appreciate attentive service, this spot delivers value and flavor in equal measure. It’s a must-try for locals and visitors alike, proving that great pizza doesn’t have to be flashy—just honest and delicious.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
  • Service options
    • Kerbside pickup
    • No-contact delivery
    • Delivery
    • Drive-through
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards